Securing a Valuable NIL Deal as a Non-Star Athlete: Strategies for Success
- Wolfe Sports Recruiting
- May 28
- 6 min read
Updated: Sep 23
Message: Invest in personal branding and creating a life vision.
While high-profile athletes in football, basketball, and baseball often dominate headlines with lucrative NIL deals, athletes in less visible sports or lower on the depth chart—such as a third-string quarterback or those in sports like soccer, gymnastics, volleyball, or wrestling—can also secure valuable NIL deals. The key lies in leveraging your unique story, building a strong personal brand, and strategically targeting opportunities that align with your strengths. This article outlines actionable steps to help non-star athletes maximize their NIL potential, regardless of their sport or role on the team.
Support US!
Subscribing to our YouTube is an amazing free way to support!
Get your $10 Sports Recruiting Navigation Guide: Athlete, Parent, and Coach Approved!
Understanding the NIL Landscape
Since the NCAA’s rule change, college athletes across all sports have earned NIL deals, with the market projected to reach $1.17 billion in 2025, according to industry reports. While top-tier athletes in high-revenue sports secure deals with national brands, non-star athletes can tap into local businesses, niche markets, and digital platforms to generate income. For example, a third-string quarterback or a gymnast may not have the visibility of a star player, but their authenticity, niche audience, and dedication can attract sponsors looking for relatable and engaged ambassadors.
Why Non-Star Athletes Can Succeed in NIL
Non-star athletes have unique advantages in the NIL space:
Authenticity: Fans often connect with underdogs or athletes in less mainstream sports, valuing their grit and relatability.
Niche Audiences: Sports like lacrosse or cheerleading have dedicated fanbases, creating opportunities for targeted sponsorships.
Accessibility: Smaller brands prefer working with athletes who have manageable, engaged audiences rather than competing for high-profile stars.
Diverse Skills: Non-star athletes often have compelling stories of perseverance, making them ideal for brands seeking inspirational figures.
With the right approach, a third-string quarterback or a golfer can secure deals ranging from a few hundred dollars to thousands per campaign, building both income and a professional brand for the future.
Strategies for Securing Valuable NIL Deals
1. Build a Strong Personal Brand
Your personal brand is your most powerful asset in securing NIL deals. It reflects who you are, what you stand for, and why brands should invest in you. Here’s how to craft it:
Define Your Story: Reflect on what makes you unique. Are you a third-string quarterback who trains relentlessly? A gymnast who overcame injury? Write a concise personal statement, such as: “I’m a dedicated student-athlete passionate about inspiring others and improving the food and health care system.”
Showcase Your Personality: Use social media platforms like X, Instagram, or TikTok to share your journey. Post about your training, team camaraderie, or community involvement to build an authentic connection with followers.
Highlight Transferable Skills: Emphasize skills like discipline, teamwork, or leadership. For example, a soccer player could share content about their work ethic, appealing to fitness brands.
2. Leverage Social Media Effectively
Social media is a critical tool for non-star athletes to gain visibility and attract NIL deals. Even with a modest following, you can make an impact:
Create Consistent Content: Post regularly about your sport, training routines, or personal interests. For instance, a wrestler could share strength training tips, while a cheerleader might post about choreography or team spirit.
Engage Your Audience: Respond to comments and messages to build a loyal, engaged following. Brands value engagement rates (likes, comments, shares) over raw follower count.
Use Relevant Hashtags: Include hashtags like #NIL, #StudentAthlete, or sport-specific tags (e.g., #CollegeLacrosse) to increase discoverability. On X, tag local businesses or brands you’d like to work with.
Optimize Your Profiles: Ensure your bio includes your sport, school, and contact information (e.g., a professional email or link to a portfolio). Keep profiles clean and professional, as brands often review social media before offering deals.
3. Target Local and Niche Brands
Non-star athletes are well-positioned to secure deals with local businesses and niche brands that align with their sport or story:
Local Businesses: Reach out to restaurants, gyms, or car dealerships in your college town. For example, a third-string quarterback could partner with a local sports bar for game-day promotions.
Sport-Specific Brands: Target brands that cater to your sport, such as gymnastics apparel companies or wrestling gear manufacturers. Even small brands value athletes who resonate with their audience.
Community Organizations: Partner with local charities or youth programs. A golfer could offer clinics at a community center, earning a deal while building goodwill.
How to Pitch: Send a professional email or direct message introducing yourself, highlighting your audience (e.g., “I have 2,000 engaged followers interested in fitness”), and proposing a collaboration (e.g., social media posts, event appearances). Include a link to your highlight reel or portfolio.
4. Create a Professional Portfolio
A digital portfolio showcases your value to potential sponsors. Include:
Highlight Reel: A 1-2 minute video of your best plays or performances, even if you’re not a starter. For example, a third-string quarterback could include practice footage or leadership moments.
Athletic and Academic Stats: List your achievements, such as team contributions, GPA, or awards.
Testimonials: Include quotes from coaches or teammates about your work ethic or character.
Social Media Metrics: Highlight your follower count, engagement rate, and audience demographics.
Host your portfolio on a free platform like Wix or Google Sites and share the link in outreach emails. This professional touch sets you apart from other athletes.
5. Network at Events and Camps
College camps, showcases, and community events are opportunities to connect with potential sponsors and build your brand:
Attend with Intent: Bring business cards or a digital QR code linking to your portfolio. Introduce yourself to attendees, including local business owners or brand representatives.
Follow Up: After an event, send a polite email or X message to contacts you met, referencing your conversation and proposing a partnership.
Showcase Leadership: Volunteer to lead drills or speak at events, increasing your visibility. For example, a lacrosse player could host a youth clinic, attracting attention from local sponsors.
6. Collaborate with Teammates
Team up with other athletes to amplify your reach. For example:
Group Content: Create joint content with teammates, such as a TikTok challenge or training video, to attract a larger audience.
Shared Deals: Approach brands as a group to offer broader exposure. A cheerleading squad could pitch a deal to a local fitness studio, splitting the earnings.
Cross-Promotion: Promote each other’s profiles to grow your followings, making you more attractive to sponsors.
7. Explore Digital and Content Creation Opportunities
Non-star athletes can generate income through digital platforms, even with smaller audiences:
YouTube or TikTok: Create tutorials, vlogs, or behind-the-scenes content about your sport or lifestyle. Monetize through ads or brand partnerships.
Blogs or Newsletters: Write about topics like recovery tips or nutrition, attracting niche sponsors like supplement companies.
Online Coaching: Offer virtual training sessions or nutrition advice, leveraging your athletic experience. For example, a softball player could sell hitting tips via Zoom.
Key Tips for Maximizing Deal Value
Negotiate Smartly: Don’t undervalue your worth. Even small deals ($100-$500) can add up. Propose deliverables like multiple posts or event appearances to increase value.
Be Professional: Deliver on promises (e.g., posting on time) and maintain a positive image. Brands value reliability.
Track Metrics: Use tools like Instagram Insights to show brands your engagement rates, strengthening your pitch.
Diversify Income: Combine social media deals, appearances, and digital content to create multiple revenue streams.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
Unprofessional Content: Avoid posting controversial or inappropriate content, as brands scrutinize social media.
Generic Pitches: Tailor outreach to each brand, showing genuine interest in their products.
Ignoring Compliance: Follow NCAA and school NIL guidelines to avoid eligibility issues. Consult your compliance office before signing deals.
Focusing Only on Big Brands: Smaller, local deals are often easier to secure and can lead to long-term partnerships.
Real-World Examples
Gymnast with Local Impact: A Division I gymnast with 5,000 Instagram followers partnered with a local yoga studio for $300 per post, promoting classes to her fitness-focused audience.
Third-String Quarterback’s Hustle: A backup quarterback used X to share leadership tips, landing a $500 deal with a local car dealership for a game-day appearance.
Soccer Player’s Niche Deal: A women’s soccer player secured a $200 monthly deal with a sports nutrition brand by posting about their products on TikTok.
Conclusion
Securing a valuable NIL deal as a non-star athlete or in a less prominent sport requires creativity, persistence, and a strong personal brand. By defining your unique story, leveraging social media, targeting local and niche brands, and building a professional portfolio, you can attract sponsors and generate income, even as a third-string quarterback or an athlete in sports like golf or wrestling. Start early, stay authentic, and approach NIL with the same dedication you bring to your sport. With strategic effort, you can turn your collegiate experience into a launching pad for financial success and a lasting professional brand.
Support US!
Subscribing to our YouTube is an amazing free way to support!
Get your $10 Sports Recruiting Navigation Guide: Athlete, Parent, and Coach Approved!
Comments